PMA Readers’ Favorite Albums of 2011

HOUSE OF BALLOONS
Listen to our FAVORITE SONGS OF 2014 or LAUNCH PMA RADIO. Make sure you don't miss any tunes: FOLLOW US ON TWITTER.

A few weeks ago we asked you all what your favorite albums of 2011 were, and now that we’ve shared our lists, we’ve tallied up the results.

By a wide margin, Pretty Much Amazing readers’ favorite album of 2011 was actually a free mixtape, The Weeknd’s groundbreaking House of Balloons. It’s notable that Abel Tesfaye’s other mixtape, Thursday failed to make it on the list at all (Ed. note: Echoes of Silence had not been release at the time of polling).

Coming in at number two is another Year-End List staple, Bon Iver’s self-titled summer LP, who beat out Fleet Foxes’ Helplessness Blues by an even wider margin. Two blockbuster albums, Hov & Ye’s Watch The Throne (#4) and Drake’s Take Care (#6), make an appearance in the top 10; 2011’s best selling album (by far), Adele’s 21 also shows up at #13.

2011 brought us plenty of great debut albums, and it was this category that held the most surprises. House of Balloons aside, Youth Lagoon’s The Year of Hibernation (#5) was the favorite debut album the year, beating out James Blake (#6), Cults (#9) and Frank Ocean (#10). Another surprise was that the ever-popular and think-piece-generating Tyler The Creator failed to get a single mention from PMA readers for his Goblin LP, which matches the critics’ sentiments toward the album (it only showed up on one list).

The rest of the top 30 is made up of favorites from our lists and others. Overall, it’s a selection of albums that effectively captures of the sound of 2011; a list I believe few can argue with. Well done, you.

PMA Readers’ Top 30 Albums of 2011
1. The WeekndHouse of Balloons (190 points)

2. Bon IverBon Iver, Bon Iver (150)
3. Fleet FoxesHelplessness Blues (102)
4. Jay-Z & Kanye WestWatch The Throne (93)
5. Youth LagoonThe Year of Hibernation (70)
6. DrakeTake Care (65)
6. James BlakeJames Blake (65)
8. M83Hurry Up, We’re Dreaming (64)
9. CultsCults (60)
10. Frank OceanNostalgia, ULTRA. (57)

11. Florence + The MachineCeremonials (53)
12. Tune-Yardswhokill (50)
13. Adele21 (46)
14. Childish GambinoCamp (44)
15. The AntlersBurst Apart (40)
15. WU LYFGo Tell Fire To The Mountain (40)
17. St VincentStrange Mercy (37)
18. WilcoThe Whole Love (35)
19. Beyonce4 (34)
20. Gil Scott-Heron & Jamie xxWe’re New Here (30)
20. GirlsFather, Son, Holy Ghost (30)
20. Little DragonRitual Union (30)
20. RadioheadThe King of Limbs (30)
24. Atlas SoundParallax (25)
24. Katy BOn A Mission (25)
24. Lykke LiWounded Rhymes (25)
24. Panda BearTomboy (25)
24. SBTRKTSBTRKT (25)
24. Washed OutWithin and Without (25)
24. YuckYuck (25)

What did you think?
 63  14  1  2
chance the rapper
MP3

In their his new remix with his band the Social Experiment, Chance the Rapper joins J. Cole…

Hot Chip
Music

Reminder: Hot Chip are releasing their new album, Why Make Sense? next month. We’ve already…

Tallest-Man-on-Earth
Music

Swedish singer-songwriter Kristian Matsson records as The Tallest Man on Earth, and has been doing…

jamie xx in colour
Videos

The xx‘s beatmaker Jamie xx is releasing his first solo LP, In Colour, this summer. He has already…

torres-min
Music

With the support of an impressive, and representative, string of singles (“Cowboy Guilt”, “Strange Hellos”,…

Brandon_Flowers_The_Desired_Effect-min
Music

On May 18, the Killers’ frontman Brandon Flowers will release his second solo album, The…

blur the magic whip
Reviews

The new album from Blur happens to be grand, assured, and terrific.

braids deep in the iris-min
Reviews

“Sit down / with emotion, / take the time to feel it.”

Bat For Lashes
Music

Bat For Lashes doesn’t always collaborate with others, but when she does, it’s usually really,…