Make sure to download the newest episode of the pmaCAST: Looking Better, Shining Brighter Than You Do, featuring Four Tet, Yeah Yeah Yeahs, The xx, Yeasayer, Department of Eagles, Hot Chip and more.
I have a dirty little secret. I like American Idol. Why? Well because I like talent, and the people on American Idol are usually talented. But after the first few seasons I got really annoyed during the first few weeks, so I made a promise to myself, I will only watch American Idol after the Top 12 have been announced. And that’s what I have been doing for the last 4 years or so.
So last night’s Top 12 Performances were nothing short of breath taking, for the most part. Some (stop to click the link) were freaky (click again), though. Here are my premature picks at the top 3.
David Archuleta. Is this a surprise to anyone? Even, I, who have been trying to stay away form AI till now, have heard of this kid. He is like the new Sanjaya, but with immense talent, boyish good looks that can make your grandmother blush, and the kid drips of charisma. Even though he messed up a bit last night, he was still killer. His voice is great, he dresses even better.
David Archuleta – We Can Work It Out (Beatles) [via Rickey]
Amanda Overmyer. This nurse has the best voice in American Idol history, no doubt. The “bad girl” vibe is surrounding this songbird, reminiscent of Duffy or Amy Winehouse. We need a Wino in America guys! She’s it!
Amanda Overmyer – You Can’t Do That [via Rickey]
David Cook. Well look at this, another Daughtry. But this one sounds as if he might be more than a Nickelback clone. Listen to the MP3, its just perfect. An Alt. Rock interpretation of “Eleanor Rigby” — stupendous.
David Cook – Eleanor Rigby [via Rickey]
But when it comes down to it, who’s gonna win? David Archuleta. No doubt in my mind about that.
Tags: Amanda Overmyer, American Idol, David Archuleta, David Cook
oh yay! i love this show too!
isnt david a adorable!
Wow, I could not disagree with you more about David (hugely overrated – shut up judges, and let me decide who I like for myself) and Amanda (honestly do not think she’s that good – I appreciate that she’s something different in the pack, but she’s a mediocre one-trick pony. The more she sings, the more I’m surprised she even made it to the top 24).
I do like Mr. Cook, though. I also like Carly and Michael.
Amanda the best voice ever on Idol? Are you high? She’s f-ing horrible.
i’d have to agree with the 2 davids in the top, but i wasnt a fan of amanda. but i was a major fan of david archuleta! i love that kid and i really think he should’ve won, but i got to see him in concert, and he was amazing!
carly, michael, syesha, and ramiele and chikeze were really good too! i enjoyed all of them actually!
“But when it comes down to it, who’s gonna win? David Archuleta. No doubt in my mind about that.”