Hmmm…Pitchfork Gives U2 A 4.2

Click on the turntable on the left to listen to a continuous stream of music featured on Pretty Much Amazing - updated every day. For more, you can check out the Best Songs of 2011, or our Best Albums of 2011.

Hmmm...Pitchfork Gives U2 A 4.2 news music

Not quite sure what to make of this one.I’m surprised P4K didn’t give them a U.2.

Their critic Ryan Dombal calls No Line On The Horizon a “a defensive gesture, and a rather pitiful one at that.”

U2 has been getting both a lot of love and, well, a lot of more love lately.

What do you guys think? Have you heard No Line On The Horizon yet (if not, it’s streaming on U2′s MySpace)? Does it deserve praise or criticism?

PMA’s review will be up very shortly, probably early in this week.

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Mick March 2, 2009 at 1:29 pm

Haven’t heard it and I’m not really interested, for some reason U2 always dissapoints me, every U2 album I tried so far dissapointed me, their hitsingles are alright I guess, at least some of them are but when I listen to their albums I always get the impression Bono sits down, writes as much as he can, releases it and prays there’s something in it people will like.

Reply

Arnold March 2, 2009 at 1:56 pm

Yeah.. RS and EW would like this album. Ha, but I have to agree with P4K this time.

Are you going to keep us updated on all of their album reviews? Haha.

Reply

brentcfg@bellsouth.net March 2, 2009 at 2:00 pm

Yea no offense to the poster, but shouldn’t you guys just worry about your review instead of a different site? I mean it is just their opinion, not everyones gonna like a certain sound/album.

Reply

Luis Tovar March 2, 2009 at 2:02 pm

I agree with P4K’s review almost 100%

Reply

Adam Offitzer March 2, 2009 at 2:02 pm

Haha i just think that when pitchfork bashes such a high-profile band, it’s PMA news-worthy.

Reply

Jack March 2, 2009 at 2:03 pm

Well, Brent, Pitchfork isn’t JUST a different site. But yeah, this was an unnecessary post. Most people agree that the U2 album sucks, or isn’t very good.

News would be when P4K gave AC a 9.6 or when they gave NASA a 1.6, not giving U2 a score a bit lower than they probably deserve (5ish, imho).

Reply

brentcfg March 2, 2009 at 2:23 pm

no offense hopefully was taken by my comments, i like everything Adam has posted so far. Miniature Tigers album has been on repeat since the post!

Reply

Adam Offitzer March 2, 2009 at 4:50 pm

Brent- No offense taken. Glad you enjoy the Miniature Tigers!

However, I do feel that Pitchfork giving a band like U2 a score less than 5 is news, due to what Jake says: Pitchfork isn’t JUST a different site. it is the ultimate tastemaker in indie music.

And then I have to go and disagree with Jeff, because the reviews for U2′s album have been very, very positive. Whether you like it or not, No Line On The Horizon has got good buzz going for it- try googling U2 album review.

Get pumped for my review.

Reply

Simon March 3, 2009 at 6:12 am

U2 haven’t done a song worth a squirrel’s ass in about 16 years, why anyone still cares about them is beyond me. I’m surprised that Pitchfork even waste time reviewing their new album, they’re just a bunch of has-beens who are too cheap (all those crazy sunglasses can’t be cheap) and lazy to try and make good music again.

Reply

gary March 3, 2009 at 8:35 am

U2′s “No Line On The Horizon” MP3 Album download for $4
Today only, the Amazon MP3 Store offers downloads of U2′s No Line On The Horizon for $3.99. That’s the lowest price we could find for this 11-track, DRM-free album, released today. (iTunes charges $9.99.) Amazon MP3 Downloader is required.

Reply

Edward March 3, 2009 at 3:29 pm

What I want to know is why did PMA take it on itself to start posting recaps of everything Pitchfork does? Seriously, frequently tagging behind them on news updates is neither helpful nor appreciated — I read PMA because it delivers the jams, exclusive and breaking, and find this more distracting than productive.

More to the point, why validate Pitchfork’s hyper-self-involved opinions by giving them additional publicity (and, therein, sway)? I guess at the end of it all, I’m a little confused by what purpose this post serves at all, if not to create some ridiculous idea of “pre-hype” for PMA’s eventual review of the album. Comparing Pitchfork reviews to Rolling Stone and Entertainment Weekly is laughable. I think what the #2 and #3 posters here said gets the point across best — don’t waste your time and ours with this. Just stick to posting to fantastic music.

Reply

Tony Celia March 4, 2009 at 6:36 pm

U2′s NLOH is at its best an attempt to further vindicate the band’s relevance in today’s world. Apart from Bono’s constant philanthropist shit U2 is still a band which kicks and pulls. They are a sum of its parts rather than an individual addition. NLOH is a clear example of this, being really sparse and at times unfocused. But, it is not a 4.6 album, if anything is a 7.2 album. It is a good effort, and its clear that Brian Eno and Lenois reviewed their old Spector book for this one. The production is spacial, which I like. “Unknown Caller” and “Cedars of Lebanon” are standouts, bringing The Edge back to form. Kudos for trying, and if the hype for the unreleased tracks from the session are true then we should expect a much better album by the end of the year hopefully. One thing though: Fuck Spidey, stick with The Fly .

Reply

Leave a Comment

I can’t really get enough of this guy. Mickey Factz has been making some real music lately, and “Sensibility” only adds to the elevation of the bar his debut album,…

Keep Reading...

Too often do I get emails from people claiming so-and-so is the next biggest thing in music. Most of the time they are horribly wrong, but in Mateo‘s case, they…

Keep Reading...

Radiohead opens up this week’s podcast with a double introduction. Three Leaves and a Head’s remix of “Reckoner” is a marvelous set of lulling, dramatic pianos and snaps. It leads…

Keep Reading...

The Roots Present THE JAM @ Highline Ballroom on 3/05 @ 11:30p Want to attend with a guest? Leave a comment w/ your name and your guest’s name and your…

Keep Reading...

Delta Spirit opens for M. Ward on 3/04 @ Muse Box at the Fonda in Hollywood. Want to attend with a guest? This show IS soldout! Leave a comment w/…

Keep Reading...

Ha… yeah, that’s a Cobra Snake pic on PMA. **Cherry Popping Sound** I’ve been ignoring posting most remixes in favor of artists who demand more hype than they’ve been getting,…

Keep Reading...

As I Guess I’m Floating says, you’ve heard this a million times: “there’s this new great band with the perfect mixture of Arcade Fire, Beirut, and Clap Your Hands Say…

Keep Reading...

Bringing together the classic songwriting of Stevie Wonder with the 80s pop sensibilities of Cyndi Lauper, North London based singer songwriter Zarif creates her own brand of quirky retro-tinged soul.…

Keep Reading...

Just like Kanye’s VH1 Storytellers, this will also be epic. The much-rumored Julie Taymor/Bono collaboration on a Spiderman broadway show was finally confirmed a few days ago by Pitchfork. Called…

Keep Reading...